
How to Choose a Tax Preparer: Everything You Need to Know
Most Americans would not be surprised to learn that the US tax code consists of thousands of pages of complicated language and rules. What may be less obvious, though, is that over the last 10-15 years, the tax code has increased in its length and complexity more than at any other time in history.
Each year, there are changes to tax laws that can greatly impact your tax situation. Keeping up with these changes requires a great deal of time, effort, and expertise. That expertise, most often provided from CPA firms, can appear expensive and may lead taxpayers to pursue cheaper options. However, mistakes made or opportunities missed by self-preparers or under-qualified professionals may come at a far greater cost.
But what options for tax preparers do you have? And how do you choose one that you can be assured is qualified?
Read ahead for a guide on how to select a tax preparer who's qualified and will best meet your tax needs.
Why Do You Need a Tax Preparer for Your Business?
If you're a small business owner or an individual who's been doing your own taxes, you might be wondering why you should pay someone to do a task you've been completing yourself.
There's a reason you go to a mechanic for your car, a stylist for your hair, and even hire a plumber for your clogged drain. They specialize and are trained in what they do.
The same can be said for a tax preparer. Could you cut your hair yourself? Maybe, but if you make a mistake you might end up with a buzz cut... and the person who's trained will reduce your risk of that. The same can be said about tax preparation - you don't want the financial equivalent of a self-inflicted buzz cut!
A knowledgeable tax preparer should understand the work you do and advise you on how to reach the best outcome.
They should be more than just the person who files your taxes. They should provide strong business advice and counsel for your business too.
Preparing for Tax Season
As you consider who to hire, it's important to be preparing for tax season. In reality, this is also something an experienced tax preparer could help you do too.
You want to organize your tax information and have a systematic process for record keeping and accounting. It makes sense throughout the year to communicate and ask questions of your tax advisor, so you already know the answer when filing season rolls around.
Types of Tax Preparers:
As you consider who to hire as a tax preparer, you should know there are several sets of credentials that tax preparers might claim to have. As you vet their qualifications, it's probably helpful to know what those credentials mean.
Certified Public Accountant
A certified public accountant (CPA), has earned the highest credential in the field of accounting and tax. To earn and maintain their credentials, CPAs must pass one of the most rigorous professional exams in existence, and then keep up with dozens of hours annually in continuing education.
CPAs often establish teams of accountants who work together for the benefit of their clients. These become CPA "firms." Strong CPA firms often provide a full suite of services to their clients, combining strategic planning with accounting and tax services to boost the success levels of their clients.
Within a CPA firm, you are likely to see individuals of varied professional backgrounds and specialities, all working together for their clients.
Enrolled Agent
If you consider an enrolled agent or EA, you are hiring a tax preparer that has been approved to represent taxpayers before the IRS.
They are highly skilled and either have previous employment with the IRS or have passed an exam to earn their credentials. The IRS requires EAs to do continuing education each year in accounting methods and tax regulations, as well.
Non-Credentialed Tax Preparers
There are thousands of tax preparers across the country who don't have specific credentials to provide tax services. Within the context of a CPA firm, non-certified preparers may work closely with CPAs to provide tax, accounting, or other services. They may even be working toward or studying for the CPA examination process.
Outside the context of a CPA firm, non-certified preparers may work on their own to provide accounting and tax services. They are often able to work at a reduced rate compared to CPA firms, because they are not required to maintain the same professional standards and ongoing training requirements.
It's likely you'd use a non-credentialed tax preparer for your personal taxes if they are simple with minimal deductions and you just don't want to do them yourself.
Does the Tax Preparer Understand Your Business?
Another important consideration for a tax preparer for your business is if they know and understand the unique aspects of your business. You want a tax preparer who specializes in your business or industry.
When the tax preparer knows your industry, they will be better equipped to offer business advice. They'll also best know where to look for tax credits and deductions when it comes time for tax filing.
You might be surprised to learn that some tax preparers do specialize in different types of businesses. It's a question to ask your tax preparer as you consider them for your taxes.
Choosing a Tax Preparer:
So, now that you understand the different types of tax preparers, let's consider what you should be thinking about when you choose one to do your taxes.
Here is a list of considerations to use when you choose a tax preparer.
Website
In today's business environment, a strong professional service business understands the importance of clearly articulating its value. To gauge what your potential new accountant does best, or doesn't do at all, take a look at their website and see what message the website sends.
If the message doesn't make you feel like a good fit, or if the message is not clear, you should take that into account. If no specific expertise stands out, and it looks like they specialize in everything (or nothing), you may not receive stellar service based on your exact needs.
Qualifications
It makes sense to start by considering a tax preparer's qualifications. Of course, some of their qualifications will be addressed depending on the type of preparer you choose.
You can also ask if they're a member of any professional organization. If they work for someone else, ask what expectations there are for continuing education so they stay up to date.
Qualifications might also include their ability to provide you services beyond tax filing day and if they have any areas of specialty that meet your needs.
Referrals
Any time you hire a professional, think back to the mechanic, stylist, and plumber reference, it makes sense to ask people you know for references. Or ask the professional to provide references you can check.
If you're a business, ask other businesses like yours who does their taxes. Ask your friends, neighbors, and family for recommendations. One of the best qualifiers can be a glowing recommendation from someone else.
Don't downplay a less-than-stellar recommendation either. Ask for specifics about why a tax preparer worked well or didn't on their behalf. Once you've checked references, have an honest dialogue with the accountant about what you learned.
Check for IRS Preparer Tax Identification Number
The IRS now requires all recognized tax preparers to have a Preparer Tax Identificaiton Number to and include it on tax returns they file.
Don't hire someone who doesn't have a PTIN as they are not following the regulations of the IRS.
Check for IRS Preparer Tax Identification Number
The IRS now requires all recognized tax preparers to have a Preparer Tax Identificaiton Number to and include it on tax returns they file.
Don't hire someone who doesn't have a PTIN as they are not following the regulations of the IRS.
Expectations
You should understand clearly what you can reasonably expect of your accountant, and what he or she expects of you. This covers everything from price structure to availability to turnaround time on projects.
Before a new accountant makes a commitment to working with you, they should take it upon themselves to clearly articulate these expectations. If they don't, it could be because they aren't willing to be accountable for helping you avoid surprises.
Choose a Tax Preparer to Get Your Taxes Done Right
Above all, when you choose an accountant (or an accounting firm), you should be comfortable that they have the horsepower to meet your needs at all times, the expertise to keep you away from negative outcomes and unwanted surprises, and the skills in relationships and communication that give you continued comfort in working with them.
If you're ready for qualified tax help and a great experience, then contact us today so we can start the conversation about your needs.


